Paleo Coffee Creamer Recipe – This Is a Coffee Game Changer

Coffee is a delicious and soothing ritual for me, but as hard as I try I just can’t enjoy the “healthy” version and drink it black. So when I heard of this Paleo Coffee Creamer I knew I had to give it a shot.

Homemade Paleo Coffee Creamer - This is a coffee game changer. It only takes a few seconds to whip up and is a clean eating option for those of you who love flavored coffee creamer. | The Bewitchin Kitchen

Paleo Coffee Creamer

I really enjoy my coffee, it’s not something I care to permanently give up (although I will try to go coffee-less every once in a while out of pure torture). I have one every morning while I catch up on emails and promote some posts and then again in the afternoon while I watch Days of Our Lives (yes, it’s my guilty pleasure).

Lately, I have been drinking it with no cream and a few drops of stevia, but it just wasn’t hitting the spot for me. I’m going to be completely honest here:

I miss my chemical-filled flavored coffee creamers.

Like, a lot.

Especially the chocolate mint one.

So when my lovely coach, Jenelle Summers, posted this fun coffee trick on her Instagram: I knew I would be trying it. You can follow Jenelle on Instagram here and while you’re at it follow me too.

Paleo Coffee Creamer Step By Step Tutorial

Homemade Paleo Coffee Creamer - This is a coffee game changer. It only takes a few seconds to whip up and is a clean eating option for those of you who love flavored coffee creamer. | The Bewitchin Kitchen

Supplies needed:

I have included affiliate links for your convenience.

Step 1

Make yourself a cup of coffee. I use my Keurig 2.0, I love this thing. You can make a full carafe if you have guests over (or a long day a head), it’s very handy. I actually wrote a review on it a few weeks ago. Read my Keurig 2.0 review (there is also a delicious recipe for an Iced Maple Pumpkin Spice Latte there as well).

Blending coffee with coconut oil has amazing health benefits. Homemade Paleo Coffee Creamer - This is a coffee game changer.

Step 2

Add your coffee to a blender (I use a Vitamix and love it – read my Vitamix review for details and it’s available at Amazon.com or Amazon.ca) along with 1 tsp organic coconut oil. Yes, I said coconut oil – trust me.

Homemade Paleo Coffee Creamer - This is a coffee game changer. It only takes a few seconds to whip up and is a clean eating option for those of you who love flavored coffee creamer. | The Bewitchin Kitchen

Step 4

Blend. See the change of color? It’s like there is actual cream in there, you don’t get that by just stirring oil in your coffee. You must blend it.

Homemade Paleo Coffee Creamer - This is a coffee game changer. It only takes a few seconds to whip up and is a clean eating option for those of you who love flavored coffee creamer. | The Bewitchin Kitchen

Step 5

Enjoy.

I love how frothy the top is, it tastes like such a treat.

Paleo Coffee Creamer Variations:

I like my coffee on the sweeter side, but I was able to drink it with just coconut oil. There is something about the coconut oil that makes it sweeter, it’s so lovely.

However, I have been experimenting the past few days and if you’re looking for a little something special here is a quick recipe:

Paleo Peppermint Latte recipe - It only takes a few seconds to whip up and is a clean eating option for those of us who love lattes. | The Bewitchin Kitchen

Paleo Peppermint Latte

  • 10 oz coffee
  • 1 tsp organic coconut oil (I use this one)
  • 1/4 tsp peppermint extract
  • Stevia to taste

Put in blender and blend until smooth and creamy.

Reading this in the summer? Check out my recipe for Paleo Coffee Popsicles.

Homemade Greek Vinaigrette - homemade salad dressingYou may also like this recipe for Homemade Greek Vinaigrette!

How do you take your coffee?

Looking for more great ideas? Click here to follow me on Pinterest!
Visit Randa | The Bewitchin’ Kitchen’s profile on Pinterest.

FREE Recipe Binder

Free recipe binder printable

Are you constantly wondering what's for dinner?

When I don't meal plan I feel behind, and we usually end up ordering take out. This recipe binder will keep you organized and make life a little bit easier.

Powered by ConvertKit

products I used to make this happen Shop This Post

(may include affiliate links)

71 comments on “Paleo Coffee Creamer Recipe – This Is a Coffee Game Changer”

  1. The only thing I miss since changing to a gut- healing, clean eating, paleo diet is my coffee and delicious creamers. Thank you for this post. I knew there had to be a way to be able to enjoy my coffee again!

  2. I like my coffee sweet as well. I use a small amount of organic honey for a little added sweetness!

  3. I use to only do those very bad for you creamers. Lately what I do instead is pretty similar to yours. The only difference is I put about 1 tblsp of coconut cream from coconut milk can and about 1 tsp of coconut oil. Makes it soooo much more creamier!!!

  4. Thank you so much for posting this! I appreciate that you provided measurements. It works and is so much better than the coconut milk I’ve been using! I can’t wait to check out your other pins 🙂

  5. Curious, your recipe calls for 1 tsp of coconut oil. I’ve seen others that call for 1 tbsp but am reluctant to try because that’s 120 calories. Will 1 tsp really work to provide the results above?

    • You bet Sherri, it’s all I ever use. I’m scared of 1 tbsp for calories as well. I blend it fast and it gets the results shown.

    • I tried it this morning and you’re right, this is pretty great. I will need to find some healthy tweaks to maybe flavor it a little bit more, but with just the coconut on its own it’s definitely good. Thanks for the suggestion!

    • Try extracts! 1/4 tsp or even 1/8 tsp.

  6. I’m glad I tried it but it didn’t taste anything like the coffee mate creamer. From reading the post it sounded that way. Then I spent $35 buying all the ingredients and it’s just not similar. Maybe say it’s different but good…but not the same.

    • Hey Nicole, I never said it did but I did put out there that it’s a great replacement 🙂 It hits the spot for me. Have a great day.

  7. This worked great! It’s still not as goods regular creamer but still hits the spot!

  8. What a great idea! I made mine with almond extract instead of peppermint & it’s delicious! Thanks.

  9. Pingback: How to Improve Gut Health | Randa Derkson

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.